The ingredients for a climate game: a few dice, some red
stones and a handful of beans. With
these simple tools, the Netherlands Red Cross team gave a great simulation
yesterday of the choices smallholders face in a highly uncertain environment.
“As climate scientists we realised that only spreading climate change models
was not very useful to the people most affected. You need to inform people on
what they can do to protect themselves from climate-related disasters. How can
they deal with climate risks with incomplete information?” said Maarten van
Aalst.
The Red Cross Climate Centre has trainted
many development agencies and has even worked with members of the International
Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) on climate games.
“It was interesting to see how scientists started to calculate risks and tried to include complex calculations in their decision making process” adds van Aalst.
At IFAD’s first ever Global Staff Meeting, it was up to our staff to see if they could adapt to climate change and prevent for the impact of disasters.
“It was interesting to see how scientists started to calculate risks and tried to include complex calculations in their decision making process” adds van Aalst.
At IFAD’s first ever Global Staff Meeting, it was up to our staff to see if they could adapt to climate change and prevent for the impact of disasters.
How to play? In order to make the game not overly complex,
rainfall variability is considered as the only manifestation of climate change.
Our biggest worry is therefore that the village we live in, part of a larger
region, faces floods. There are two ways to invest our resources (represented by beans): in development work (resulting in economic
development for our own village) or in disaster risk reduction (safeguarding
assets in case our village faces floods). You roll two dice to find out whether
you are hit by a flood, or if your village has been spared. In the beginning of
the game you can invest in an early warning system. If you opt for this, you
receive a transparent cup so the number on one dice is visible. If you don’t
protect your region against floods and a flood hits, you face a great loss of
beans. If all your beans, run out – the price your village pays is a crisis.
The frustration caused by running out of beans is real! After 10 rounds, most villages did not have any more resources to
invest and had to leave the future of their villages to blind chance.
The question of how donors allocate money also came up. Are
they willing to invest in advance or only after a disaster? In the case of the game, donor money only became available
when it was already too late. The game showed in a fun and interactive way that climate change adaptation is full of challenges and uncertainties. Even though the participants all knew that floods may have large impacts on their villages – they wondered why invest in risk reduction, when they did not know if a disaster would actually hit their village. It was therefore quite attractive to spend money on short term benefits: you could only spend your money once.
“Through ASAP, we introduce disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation measures into IFAD-supported development projects. These measures range from landscape-level interventions, such as watershed afforestation and the restoration of coastal greenbelts, to communal investments in early warning systems, more robust storage infrastructure and salt- or heat-tolerant crop varieties”.
The Red Cross game showed that decision making in relation to climate change and risk management, is quite a difficult task. Even when the will and knowledge to act is there: risks are complex to deal with in a world where money is scarce.